Recently, transactions that involve the sale of personal data to foreign companies have gained more attention, and CFIUS reviews are happening with more frequency. Most transactions submitted to CFIUS are cleared. However, recent statistics have been less positive, particularly deals with a Chinese buyer or deals where companies handle personal data. For example, in April 2019 a U.S. health care company that collects personal data on approximately one million clients announced that CFIUS was forcing its Chinese majority shareholder to divest its interest. With transactions resulting from a bankruptcy proceeding now codified under CFIUS, increased focus on such transactions is likely and can affect more bankruptcy 363 asset sales. Companies that deal with personal data should be particularly aware of the concerns CFIUS may have as a result of a pending asset sale.
CFIUS reviews can also affect the timing of a sale. For example, a U.S. developer of alternative energy technologies announced that CFIUS determined that it would extend the investigation period for a merger with a U.S. subsidiary of a Danish company. This pushed back the closing date and created uncertainty about whether the transaction would go through. Bankruptcy 363 sales may also have to endure longer review periods before a sale becomes final.
Prior to FIRRMA the CFIUS review period was 30 days. Now, after CFIUS receives a filing, it has 45 days to review. CFIUS may request information from the parties during the review period. Most reviews are complete after the 45-day review period. If CFIUS is unable to resolve a national security concern during the 45-day review period, it can then initiate a 45-day investigation, which can be extended by a 15-day period in extraordinary circumstances.
It is also possible for CFIUS to reject the filing. A rejection may occur if a filing is not complete, if there is a material change in the proposed transaction, or if material information becomes available that contradicts the information previously provided. If CFIUS finds that the transaction would present a national security risk, then CFIUS may impose conditions on the transaction or may refer the case to the president who may block the transaction.
The CFIUS review process and lengthy review periods should not discourage debtors from selling to foreign entities or dealing in assets that involve personal data. There are some measures parties can take to alleviate some of the pressure a CFIUS review may place on a bankruptcy 363 sale. The parties may want to consider communicating with CFIUS early in the process. Informal communication with CFIUS can provide valuable insight into what may cause concern under a CFIUS review. If parties can anticipate the national security concerns CFIUS may have as a result of the transaction they can proactively provide possible solutions when filing their application for approval. While this will not guarantee that the sale will be allowed, it can give both parties greater piece of mind during the review periods and hopefully avoid a rejection.
Authored by Ronald Silverman and Sara Posner